This is not one of the Nantucket restaurants worth going to: service is slow and not very attentive or professional; food is well below average; and indoor ambience / decor is non-existent. But food is the most important ingredient: a 16 oz rib eye was the thinnest cut of steak I've ever been served (8 oz at most) with a bearnaise sauce that was merely a lump of butter; the new England clam chowder was extremely salty; and the appetizer of heirloom tomatoes was a strange and tasteless concoction of tomato skins floating in about half an inch of olive oil with a square of nondescript cheese; the mashed potatoes were, however, very good. Why eat here when you can go to Dune, 29 Fair Street, Galley Beach, Proprietors Inn, Brant Point Grill or so many other Nantucket restaurants that offer truly fine, creative dining options ?
New head chef is incredible. Food is fantastic. Must have the crudo and any special. Can't wait to have brunch, rumored to be best on island.
Service was good and the food was excellent. The steak and cheese sandwich was outstanding.
We dined there last night. They were kind enough to hold our reservation and gave us a nice table. No champagne by the glass, "sold out for the season". Seemed odd. I ordered the filler medium. They over cooked and it came out week done. We had a couple sides that were okay. Surprised by the high ratings. Service by Tyler was ok. Underwhelmed.
Service was terrible. Waiter never came back to see if we needed anything. No choice on how we wanted a our steak prepared. Only medium was available. No sides with dinner, just meat on a plate. Not even salt and pepper on the table! Waited over 45 minutes for a cocktail.
Go somewhere else! Not worth the price for a poorly run restaurant.
Nantucket Prime is a US Restaurant based in Nantucket, Massachusetts. Nantucket Prime is located at 29 Broad St, Nantucket, MA 02554, USA.
Please contact with Nantucket Prime using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Nantucket Prime opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.
Find Restaurant in Nantucket