Got an order to go. This is their Rustic pizza. Not convinced and probably won't be coming back for any other selection. It was mostly arugula, barely dressed or seasoned. The pancetta (barely any) was too dry. And although I am a fan on thin pizzas , this was more cracker-like.
Nicely done think crispy crust pizza. White clam was well prepared. Charcuterie plate was a good start to the meal.
Great food. Nice staff. Cody is very pleasant. Arrive early - 5:30pm to ensure yourself a table without a wait.
Four of us ate there on 9/12 at 15 minutes after they opened. We let our waiter know right away that we had another commitment, but he was not adequately attentive to our time constraints. We first waited quite awhile before our entries came, then one meal was delivered almost 10 minutes after the other three. Two orders of Chicken Piccata were terrible (the chicken cutlets were too thick and tough, and the "sauce" was lacking). It was hard to get a wait staffer's attention when we needed to get our check in order to make it to another commitment. Our meals and dining experience were truly not up to the $150 we spent.
Overall the island is in desperate need of real NYC or New Haven Ct. pizzeria.
Pizza good. Food a bit salty especially the soup. Service average. Still the best pizza on the island, but that's not saying much...
Pi Pizzeria is a US Meal Takeaway based in Nantucket, Massachusetts. Pi Pizzeria is located at 11 W Creek Rd, Nantucket, MA 02554, USA.
Please contact with Pi Pizzeria using information above: Address, Phone number, Fax, Postal code, Website address, E-mail, Facebook. Find Pi Pizzeria opening hours and driving directions or map. Find real customer reviews and ratings or write your own review.